Posts Tagged ‘Mike Leigh’

Mr. Turner: Is It Over?—Movie

January 2, 2015

To be perfectly blunt, “Mr. Turner” is a hugely disappointing bore. Two hours of watching actor Timothy Spall looking and grunting like a pig is just not entertaining on any level. “Mr. Turner” gives new meaning to the phrase, “like watching paint dry”…literally. Written and directed by the usually wonderful, Mike Leigh, “Mr. Turner” is one very long look at the life and career of 19th century British artist, J. M. W. Turner (Timothy Spall).


“Mr. Turner” deals with the artist’s latter years, so he is already a renowned artist when we meet him. He lives in London with his faithful housekeeper, Hannah (Dorothy Atkinson) and his father, William (Paul Jesson), until his father’s death. This particular casting is very bizarre because the father looks about the same age as Turner, making one think at first that the two are brothers.

Turner’s paintings become more impressionistic over the years. Not everyone is a fan of this change as we see in an amusing scene with a young Queen Victoria’s reaction to his work. Turner and his new art are the butt of jokes several times over the course of the film, often within Turner’s earshot. While his reactions are priceless, they are most definitely not enough to sustain interest in the film. Therein lies the problem with “Mr. Turner”…there is no there, there. There’s no narrative to explain the man behind the paint brush. What caused his painting style to change? There are some extraordinary scenes of Turner strapped to a boat’s masthead so he can paint what he sees, but why did he choose to do this? The film doesn’t say.  “Mr. Turner” alludes to and shows that as a human being, Turner could be quite despicable. He took some heinous (or so we are led to believe) actions within his family and we know he fathered children, but was never a real father…why?  His treatment of Hannah would today be a form of sexual harassment. However, in 19th century England, everyone was far too polite to say anything publicly. Why was he like this? The only time Turner’s mood seemed to lighten was when he was around Sophia Booth (Marion Bailey), the landlady of the boardinghouse where he often stayed. He became friendly (for him) with both Sophia and her husband. After her husband died, the two of them became more than friends. It’s worth noting that when he was at home in the company of his housekeeper, Turner was moody, dark and mean. When in the company of Mrs. Booth, he actually seemed to brighten a bit. It makes one wonder what might have happened if she had come into his life sooner.

Although “Mr. Turner” has received several awards and nominations, its allure simply escapes this reviewer. As Turner, Spall does nothing but stomp and grunt. When he does speak, he’s not easy to understand. The rest of the performances, save for that of Bailey, are there seemingly to show the speech and moirés of the day.

The only parts of “Mr. Turner” which are truly good are its cinematography and music. Cinematographer Dick Pope is extremely worthy of the special jury prize the Cannes Film Festival awarded him for the film’s cinematography. Gary Yershon’s weird and powerful score complements the movie beautifully.

“Mr. Turner” provides a lovely look at the beautiful work of J. M. W. Turner. It’s unfortunate that most of the film doesn’t measure up to that work.

1 ½ nuggets out of 4



Another Year: Another Terrific Leigh Film—Movie

February 6, 2011

Single middle-age women beware! Do not see Another Year alone.  Unless you are at the top of your game, by movie’s end you’ll want to throw yourself off a building. Another Year is that realistic.

Written and directed by Mike Leigh, Another Year is the story of a happily married older middle-aged couple, Gerri and Tom, and their very unhappy friends and relations, told through the changing of the seasons during the course of a year.

In winter we meet Gerri (Ruth Sheen), a psychotherapist, treating the most in-need- of-treatment for depression woman ever portrayed on the screen, Jane (Imelda Staunton).  Staunton’s role is brief, but memorable and shows us how kind and patient Gerri is. In winter we’re also introduced to Gerri’s secretary, Mary (Leslie Manville) and Gerry’s husband, Tom (Jim Broadbent). Spring is Mary’s story and Mary is a mess. Cute, stylish, desperately perky and very unhappily single, Mary is painful to watch.  Summer is the story of Ken (Peter Wight) and continued decline of Mary. Obese, drunk and clueless, Ken is a long-time friend of Tom and is a fatter version of Mary. Autumn introduces us to Ronnie (David Bradley), Tom’s recently widowed brother. Tom seems to keep all of his emotions buried inside and barely says a word. 

As with all Mike Leigh films, Another Year’s actors are called upon to do a lot of improvisation and boy, are they fantastic. However, this movie clearly belongs to Leslie Manville’s Mary. When Manville is on-screen, you can’t take your eyes off her, and even if you want to, Leigh won’t let you. His close-ups on Mary are relentless and force you to witness her pain, shame and heartbreak. Manville can do more with the movement of her mouth or the crinkle of her nose than most actors can do with pages of dialogue. She’s simply amazing and so believable. How she wasn’t nominated for an Academy Award is beyond comprehension. Every single woman over 45 will identify with her. It’s inconceivable to me that Another Year is written by a male. Mike Leigh really gets us women.

Depressing as Another Year is, it’s also full of wit and witty dialogue. And yes, even a sliver of hope.

4 nuggets out of 4

%d bloggers like this: